Continuing on testing the brand The Saem, I picked up their waterproof pencil eyeliners. They are the same price range, as the ones from Etude House, and their packaging is also pretty similar except for the fact that The Saem's pencils have a little bit of glitters, which let you understand that it probably contains some shimmers ;)
But, they are not retractable, and you will have to sharpen them.
They come in three colors.
A very dark green/brown, it has a kind of metallic look, with some shimmers.
A deep black with a tiny bit of shimmers.
And a brown one, pretty red-ish, also with a little shimmer.
They all glide on super easily, the formula is creamy and smooth. Handy and give you an even line.
It's smudge-able and you can definitely create a beautiful smokey eye with it.
Waterproof too, but not too hard to hard to remove at night. A bi-phase eye make up remover will do the trick without having to rub too hard.